Anybody remember the Winter brothers? They're albino (I shit you not) rockers out of Texas. (Edgar recorded "Frankenstein" but I dunno what else they've done)
Quite a few years ago the brothers got all pissy and moany about a really great comicbook that had been published. The title,"Jonah Hex: Riders of the Worm and Such" was set in the old west and had a mystical tone to it. the particular storyline featured an albino duo that were brothers and evil dabblers in the dark arts. Well the Winter's caught wind of his and sued the publisher (DC Comics) the artist (Tim Truman) and the writer (Joe R. Lansdale).
Why they sued (in my persona opinion) boils down to being thin-skinned,they either don't understand the concept of parody or thought they'd make money off of this,I don't know which.
I bring this up because that crappy film that the Arab world is using as their excuse to murder Americans is the same kind of deal. I don't think the Coptic Christian that came up with it meant it as anything other than a way to paint Islam in bad light (and it was mighty kind of Islamists to help him with that),but he's allowed to make the dumb thing anyway because the First Amendment allows for things like parody,which is ultimately what this thing ends up being due to how over the top it and generally poorly made it seems to be. The movie has had some Liberals going on about how the law does not protect your right to yell fire in a crowded theatre but I don't see this as being the same thing. Maybe if he made the film after the Libyans murdered our people then the argument could be made but even then I think it would still be parody because his film is ultimately a work of fiction and not a documentary piece in which a viewer has an expectation of the unvarnished truth or that the information being presented is genuinely factual. Ever wonder why Michael Moore is referred to as a "filmmaker" and not a "documentarian"?
Mind you I'm not all defending the Libyan murderers or even Islam and their Prophet who's so powerful that his people have to defend him against the slightest insult 24/7,I'm just saying that the asshole that made the movie had the right to do so. We as Americans also have the right to say that his movie is,moronic and that he's not helping matters any,but it's still his right and I'll defend that right,if not the actual idiot exercising his right.
Fortunately in the case I cited at the beginning of this blog post nobody was killed because the Winter's got their noses all out of joint. They had a nice little lawsuit and DC Comics and Lansdale and Truman won (as they should have) because they showed that their work was intended to parodize the Winters' and other musicians as well as,to a degree,the Western genre. If anything Lansdale and Truman,who are also musicians,meant for the characters that got the attention of the Winters to be a tribute rather than an attack.
My ultimate point here is that the Winters had no case to say they were being maliciously attacked or maligned by the comicbook and neither does the Muslim community in the case of this recent movie.
In both cases the offended party has come away looking far worse off than the the things that offended them would have made them look.
Maybe those Muslims need to read some Jonah Hex comics?
http://cbldf.org/about-us/case-files/jonah-hex/
